capitol hill dome open
That’s My Congress
A politically independent journal of the campaigns and legislation of the United States Congress.
  • Home
  • Special Topics
  • Contact

Republicans Try To Outlaw In Vitro Fertilization

Posted on May 10 2008 by Congress Watcher

Georgia Republican Paul Broun seems to be working as fast as he can to earn the title Official Kook of the United States Congress. Representative Broun hasn’t been in the House of Representatives for very long, but in his short time there, he’s managed to introduce a surprising number of bills that represent a very odd reinterpretation of American life.

H.R. 4157, which Representative Broun refers to as the Sanctity of Human Life Act, might more accurately be entitled the Zygote Political Enfranchisement Act or the Anti-Fertility Act. The legislation has been written by Congressman Broun in order to define a human egg created in the United States from the moment of fertilization, through its development into a fetus ready to be born, as a complete person with full legal rights and constitutional protections equal to that of any other American citizen.

Under Broun’s proposed law, this award of full legal protections to all fertilized eggs, even one created just one minute ago, would be given regardless of the ability of the fertilized egg to implant in a womb and grow to become a baby. H.R. 4157 states this very directly:

“the life of each human being begins with fertilization, cloning, or its functional equivalent, irrespective of sex, health, function or disability, defect, stage of biological development, or condition of dependency, at which time every human being shall have all the legal and constitutional attributes and privileges of personhood.”

A fertilized egg must be given all the legal protections of a person, irrespective of health, function or disability? That means that even if a fertilized egg or blastula (a tiny hollow ball of human cells post-fertilization) is somehow determined to have a terrible genetic disease, it would nonetheless have to be given full medical treatment in order to make sure that it survived to be born. If that treatment was not given, its parents could be criminally charged with child abuse or neglect.

Think about in vitro fertilization, and you’ll see how absurd this new law would be. The way that in vitro fertilization works is that many eggs are fertilized, and then sorted, so that healthy fertilized eggs are separated from the unhealthy ones. Under Paul Broun’s law, the unhealthy fertilized eggs would have to be implanted in a woman’s womb, just like the unhealthy ones. Remember that the law says that “health” and “function” are irrelevant. So, even “fertilized” eggs in which the nucleus of the sperm and egg somehow failed to unite to create a genetically coherent union would have to be implanted in a woman’s womb as if they were viable. Function doesn’t matter, according to Congressman Broun, and even fertilization is defined in his law in such a way that makes the threshold of humanity absurd:

“The term ‘fertilization’ means the process of a human spermatozoan penetrating the cell membrane of a human oocyte to create a human zygote, a one-celled human embryo, which is a new unique human being.”

Yes, according to Representative Broun, all fertilization requires is for a sperm to break through the cell membrane of a human oocyte (egg). Even if the sperm’s genetic material fails to unite with the egg’s, Paul Broun’s law counts the result as a human being with full constitutional rights to equal protection under the law.

The expense of going through full fertility procedures even with fertilized eggs that could never be successfully implanted in a woman’s womb would make in vitro fertilization unattainable for all but the most wealthy American couples. Even for those couples, however, the practical cost could be too much to bear.

Remember that under Paul Broun’s proposed law, all fertilized eggs would have full legal protections. If an in vitro fertilization process created 15 fertilized eggs for a couple, 8 of which could survive as healthy infants if implanted, then all 15 fertilized eggs would have to be implanted, including all 8 viable ones. Those eggs would be human beings with full legal rights, after all. So, either the couple would have to have all 8 children, or they would have to find seven other women who would be willing to adopt their fertilized eggs, going through pregnancy with these children that weren’t their own, and then raising those children to adulthood.

These financial and other practical requirements for in vitro fertilization would end the availability of in vitro fertilization for couples in the United States. Even American couples who went to Canada to have the procedure done could then be charged as murderers upon re-entering the United States.

That makes H.R. 4157, in effect, a bill to ban in vitro fertilization.

Anyone who is aware of the present day issues surrounding fertility treatments like in vitro fertilization realizes that giving a fertilized egg all the legal protections of a person from the moment a sperm breaks through the egg’s cell membrane is absurd. It doesn’t take a genius to see that H.R. 4157 could never be practically applied without creating some extremely bizarre consequences.

Yet, 56 members of Congress are apparently not bright enough to understand these problems. In addition to Paul Broun, 55 members of the House of Representatives support this poorly planned and ideologically extremist legislation. Their names are:

Todd Akin
Rodney Alexander
Rob Bishop
John Boozman
Dan Burton
John Carter
Steve Chabot
Michael Conaway
David Davis
Mary Fallin
Tom Feeney
Randy Forbes
Luis Fortuno
Trent Franks
Scott Garrett
Phil Gingrey
Virgil Goode
Jeb Hensarling
Wally Herger
Bob Inglis
Sam Johnson
Walter Jones
Steve King
Jack Kingston
John Kline
Doug Lamborn
John Linder
Donald Manzullo
Kenny Marchant
Michael McCaul
Patrick McHenry
Jeff Miller
Marilyn Musgrave
Randy Neugebauer
Ron Paul
Mike Pence
Charles Pickering
Joseph Pitts
Rick Renzi
Harold Rogers
Peter Roskam
Bill Sali
Jean Schmidt
Christopher Smith
Tom Tancredo
Terry Lee
Todd Tiahrt
Tim Walberg
Zach Wamp
David Weldon
Lynn Westmoreland

These members of the House of Representatives have all signed on as co-sponsors to H.R. 4157. If you see the name of your Representative here, please, make a telephone call to your Representative’s office through the congressional switchboard at (202) 224-3121, and ask for the cosponsorship to be rescinded.

It’s a matter of simple intelligence. Any member of Congress that cosponsors this H.R. 4157 has indicated either tremendous stupidity or intellectual laziness, and is unfit to serve on Capitol Hill.

Tags: abortion, alexanderlouisiana5, blastula, Bob Inglis, boozmanarkansas3, broungeorgia10, cartertexas31, Charles Pickering, congress, dealgeorgia9, Donald Manzullo, Duncan Hunter, fallinoklahoma5, fertility, fortunopuertorico1, gohmerttexas1, hergercalifornia2, human, huntercalifornia52, in vitro, inglissouthcarolina4, Jack Kingston, Jean Schmidt, Jeff Miller, John Boozman, John Carter, John Linder, johnsontexas3, kingstongeorgia1, lindergeorgia7, Louie Gohmert, Luis Fortuno, manzulloillinois16, Mary Fallin, mccaultexas10, Michael McCaul, millerflorida1, Nathan Deal, paul broun, pickeringmississippi3, renziarizona1, reproductive rights, republicans, Rick Renzi, Rodney Alexander, Sam Johnson, schmidtohio2, tiahrtkansas4, Todd Tiahrt, Wally Herger, wamptennessee3, Zach Wamp, zygote

7 Responses to “Republicans Try To Outlaw In Vitro Fertilization”

  1. Irregular Times: News Unfit for Print » Zygotes With Handguns Act Advances in Congress says:
    May 12, 2008 at 6:54 am

    [...] Paul Broun from Georgia has introduced legislation, H.R. 4157, which would give a human egg, from the moment that a sperm penetrates its cell [...]

  2. Paul Broun Invokes The Spirit Of Martin Scott; Introduces “Personhood” Bill | Peach Pundit says:
    May 12, 2008 at 10:50 am

    [...] Source: 5/10/2008 That’s My Congress blog “Republicans Try To Outlaw In Vitro Fertilization” [...]

  3. Virgil Goode Signs on to End In Vitro Fertilization « Heartland Of Virginia says:
    May 13, 2008 at 4:35 pm

    [...] Goode Signs on to End In Vitro Fertilization At a great blog called “That’s My Congress”, there is a story about Georgia Republican Paul Broun and his ‘Sanctity of Human Life [...]

  4. Virgil Goode Just Can’t Stop « Jeremy Beales says:
    May 14, 2008 at 4:21 am

    [...] went on a bizarre rant against Muslims. Now, I see that he’s signed on to a bill that would outlaw in vitro fertilization. H.R. 4157, which Representative Broun refers to as the Sanctity of Human Life Act, might more [...]

  5. Pandagon :: Georgia wingnut to revive federal marriage amendment :: May :: 2008 says:
    May 21, 2008 at 9:37 pm

    [...] of Human Life Act, called the Zygote Political Enfranchisement Act or the Anti-Fertility Act by That’s My Congress. Under Broun’s proposed law, this award of full legal protections to all fertilized eggs, even [...]

  6. Irregular Times: News Unfit for Print » Blog Archive » Republicans Promote Pistol-Packing Census-Counted Zygotes says:
    December 16, 2009 at 4:43 pm

    [...] Embryos Created by In Vitro Fertilization They’ve got all the privileges of personhood, so each and every one of those fertilized eggs created in invitro fertilization procedures must be implanted. To do otherwise would be to commit [...]

  7. That’s My Congress » Paul Broun Resurrects Bill to Create Big Government Intervention in the Womb says:
    December 16, 2009 at 5:28 pm

    [...] are promoting the radical expansion of government power with great vigor. In the 110th Congress, Broun introduced a bill that would have imbued any fertilized egg with “all the legal and constitutional attributes [...]

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

Vito Fossella Infidelity to the Constitution Matters More
Baby Turtle Pet Legislation Threatens American Ecology
  • red congress banner
  • Recent Comments

    • Judy Booker on Jo Bonner Parties While The Gulf Burns
    • Congressional Aid on Allen West Says Coexistence Must Go. Florida Republicans Say OK.
    • Randy on Allen West Says Coexistence Must Go. Florida Republicans Say OK.
    • c.ecker on Paula Brooks is Right: Pat Tiberi Does Nothing to Foster Job Creation
  • RSS Legislative News

    • OH-12: Pat Tiberi Talks Jobs But Does Nothing to Create Them
    • What Health Care Reform Disasters Have You Seen?
    • David Vitter Is Sinking Our Ship
    • Offshore Drilling Greed Is Back Again
    • Obama Seeking To Make Patriot Act More Abusive
    • Small Coalition Stands Against Killing Americans
  • Legislative Scorecards

    House Scorecards:
    ... Overall
    ... Discrimination
    ... Environment
    ... Constitution
    ... Economy
    ... LGBT

    Senate Scorecards:
    ... Overall ... Discrimination
    ... Environment
    ... Constitution
    ... Economy
    ... LGBT

    110th Congress:
    ... House
    ... Senate

  • This Week In Congress Newsletter

    Receive our This Week in Congress Newsletter by e-mail:



    Our Privacy Commitment: We will not sell or give your e-mail address to any other person or company. We will only send you our This Week in Congress Newsletter, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

  • Recent Posts

    • Michael Stopa Unites Religious Bigotries
    • Majority of Pat Tiberi campaign cash comes from Out Of State
    • Christine O’Donnell Seeks To Remove Constitutional Rights
    • Abbott Laboratories Coordinated Contributions Prop Up Steve Stivers
    • Jackson Lee on Banning Mosques: It’s About Freedom of Religion
    • Raese Maneuvers To Support Coal Executives, Not Coal Workers
    • West Virginia Senate Candidate Rails Against Non-Existent Cap and Trade Legislation
    • Lynn Westmoreland Maintains His Perfect Record
  • Tags

    afghanistan california campaign finance christianity climate change coal congress constitution cosponsorship deepwater horizon democrats dennis kucinich economy energy environment equality fisa amendments act florida fundraising global warming Green Party gulf of mexico health care house lgbt lobbyists marriage military new york obama oceans offshore drilling oil oil spill pacs patriot act paul broun pollution religion republican senate spending spying surveillance war
  • Categories

    • Activism
    • All Articles
    • campaign gear
    • caucuses
    • Ethics
    • Events
    • Featured
    • House campaigns
    • House hearings
    • House legislation
    • Ideas
    • Links
    • Personalities
    • Podcasts
    • Power Plays
    • questions
    • Senate campaigns
    • Senate hearings
    • Senate legislation
    • Site News
  • Older Articles

  • Newsfeeds

    RSSTMC Articles
    RSSComments
    RSS5 Most Liberal Senators
    RSS5 Most Conservative Senators
    RSS5 Most Liberal Representatives
    RSS5 Most Conservative Representatives

  • Archives

    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009
    • May 2009
    • April 2009
    • March 2009
    • February 2009
    • January 2009
    • December 2008
    • November 2008
    • September 2008
    • August 2008
    • July 2008
    • June 2008
    • May 2008
    • April 2008
    • March 2008
    • February 2008
    • January 2008
    • December 2007
    • November 2007
    • October 2007
    • August 2007
    • May 2007
    • April 2007
    • March 2007
    • November 2006
    • October 2006
    • September 2006
    • August 2006
    • July 2006
    • June 2006
    • May 2006
    • April 2006
    • March 2006
    • February 2006
    • January 2006

Admin


Log in

Copyright © 2010 That’s My Congress - Wordpress Theme developed by Web Hosting Fan